I just love stories about how a book cover came to be—the process of working with a publisher’s design team and models, or for some of the more creative among us, how you designed your own cover. Or in my case, how my husband designs the covers for my books. (He designed these beauties below!)
But maybe a more accurate title for this blog post would be “A Different Kind of Title Story.” My novel Beneath a Southern Sky was the fourth book I wrote (twenty years ago now!) and it was contracted by WaterBrook Press after my first three books were published by Bethany House Publishers. The reason this book (and my next three) were published by a different publishing house is a story for another time, but this was the first time my publisher let me keep my original title. That’s right. When you write for a traditional publisher, you may not get to use your first choice of titles.
So I was thrilled that WaterBrook Press liked my title, and I was even more thrilled when we searched amazon.com for other books with the same title and found there was nothing like it! That’s pretty rare! A couple of years after my book was released, a non-fiction book was published called Beneath Southern Skies. But for a long time, that was the only book with a similar title.
Fast forward about fifteen years and the floodgates opened! If you search for my title now, you will find nine titles that have Beneath a S_______ Sky in common, another dozen that have Beneath a _______ Sky in the title (most of those have the same number of syllables and rhythm as Beneath a Southern Sky.) Even more interesting: Almost every one of these books has been published within the last five years, several of them this year alone!
You’ll find titles with Beneath an _______ Sky, including Indian, Irish, and Italian skies, and then more titles with Beneath the _______ Sky. (There were a couple I didn’t include because the covers were a little on the racy side.)
Here are some titles with Beneath _______ Skies (plural) including two more Beneath Southern Skies!
There are more in the Fantasy/Science Fiction genre:
And still more in the non-fiction genre:
I’m especially fond of the title Beneath Missouri Skies now that we live in Missouri. Texas, Oklahoma, and Iowa are also represented. And in addition to Southern skies, I noticed there are now Northern and Western sky titles. (Maybe I should write a book called Beneath an Eastern Sky, just to round things out!)
There are two starless skies, two star-lit skies (and one starlet sky!) And if I really stretch the cover “copycats” I could add these titles, which continue the “beneath/under the _______ stars/sky” theme:
I’d like to think that my novel was the impetus for these dozens of almost-identical and similar titles. However, that last group is actually a great example of how authors come up with unique and different titles—a task that becomes more of a challenge every year with thousands of new books being published. If it’s not obvious by now, a title idea often comes by twisting and reshaping an existing title to fit your story and make it your own.
It helps if there is an unusual name or place in your title. Mitford in a title is a pretty sure bet that the book was written by Jan Karon. And you will only find one book titled The Guernsey Literary and Potato Peel Pie Society. (But it’s a good one!)
I still always hope to come up with a wonderful title that no one else on earth has ever used. That’s rare. And since titles can’t be copyrighted, it’s perfectly fine to have all these books with similar titles. The downside is that you never want a reader to request your novel and end up with another author’s same-titled book!
Have you ever chosen a book simply because you liked the title? Have you ever accidentally read the “wrong” book because it had the same title as the book you thought you were getting? Maybe you’ve discovered a new author that way! No matter what the title of the book you’re currently reading, I hope it’s a good one!
Latest posts by Deborah Raney (see all)
- Happy Mother’s Day! - May 11, 2025
- Research Trip - April 28, 2025
- He is Risen! - April 20, 2025
Fascinating, Deb! I can’t believe there are THAT MANY books with the same or similar titles to yours. Extraordinary.
I always do run a search for a title I’m considering and I hope dozens of books don’t come up in response but I’ve given up hoping that zero books come up. There are just way too many books out there now to hope that I’ll be able to give my novels an unique title. Maybe I should name my next one Beneath an Eastern Sky (since it will be set in Maine)… 😉
Haha! I’d read that book set in Maine! And we hope to visit there for the first time this fall!
Wow! Can’t believe how many the same and similar titles you found! Although why I say that, I am not sure. A thousand new books are published every day on Amazon. With that many new books published daily, it is more and more difficult to come up with a unique title.
My next book has a well-used title (I’ll Be Seeing You, which is a popular WWII song so it is the title of many WWII books, both fiction and non-fiction). I knew that was the case, but decided it was worth it. The title just fit the book.
I do think when the rubber hits the road, sometimes you just have to go with the title that fits your book, even if there are others with the same or similar title. In your case, Robin, I think readers are asking for YOUR new book, WHATEVER the title!
Amazing study, Deb. Makes me want to write a “Beneath a Florida Sky” or some such thing. 😉 I’m not good at titles, which is probably why some many of my older titles were one or two words, perferably with “THE” in front.
Delicious details! Thanks for enteraining us on a Monday morning!
Glad you found it interesting. I sure did! I think one of us once did a blog post on bookcovers that used the same image. I’ll have to see if I can find the link to that one.
I can see it now…Beneath a Minnesota Sky. I’d tell the story of how the mosquitoes are so abundant 🤮 this year they could carry you away to places of dreams and wishes.